300

[featherynscale]

kittenpants, orcjohn, triadruid and I managed to see 300 last night. For the entire length of the movie, three of us sat there like Beavis and Butthead; "This is the coolest thing I have ever seen. huh-huh, huh-huh". Apparently, the thing was too comic-bookish for triadruid's tastes, and he was disappointed. The rest of us reveled in that.

Beautiful art direction, brilliant action sequences, explosions (the Persians had some black-powder bombs, which I'm not sure are correct to the period, but so what?), nice looking men, an excessively hot queen, revenge, glorious doomed gestures, and a rhinoceros. What's better than that? (Well, it would have been better if the captain's son and the blond Spartan he kept bantering with had actually had sex, instead of merely flirting, but that's apparently too much to ask for.)

The Persians were, on the whole, ridiculous. When I eventually grasped that the story was being told afterwards by a soldier to the council, it made a little more sense. I mean, that's what you'd say, right? "There were six million of them! They were monstrous and deformed, and came riding strange beasts. Giants walked among them. Xerxes himself must have been 12 feet tall, and advanced upon us on a golden throne borne by thirty thousand slaves..." All it lacked was the requisite introduction: "No shit, there I was...."

The big question in everyone's mind after the film (other than "Why is it okay to show that much blood and gore and corpses and naked women and transsexual amputees and all that, and you still get an R rating, but if you show a penis, it's NC-17?" and "Why did the Spartans call the Athenians boy-lovers?" and "Why no soldier-on-soldier sex, dammit?") was this:
At that tech level, how do you get a rhinoceros on a boat, *keep* the rhinoceros on the boat, and keep the boat seaworthy, i.e. with no holes in it from rampaging rhinoceros? Discuss.

Comments

[featherynscale.livejournal.com]

Eh. I am with you on the fact that the fighting style was not what the man described as the strength and valor of his soldiers, but, on the other hand, more phalanx time would have required the film to have more plot, being as it's not real exciting to watch. Plot was not really the strong suit, here. Presumably the Spartans were the good guys, in that they talked a lot about freedom, and presumably the Persians were the bad guys, because they were weird looking, but really, the story is about a big eff-off fight. And it's a lot more visually interesting to have them fighting all crazy than to have them fighting in a historically accurate and reasonable way.

Same again with the hunchback. There was no reason for it, except that it made it blindingly obvious that he wasn't going to fit into the Spartan Superman Army. Again, I think it's a choice made for more visual interest.

The goatee Spartan was not terribly impressive, so I am with you there. The outfits of the queen, yes, stupid, but that wasn't particularly offensive to me. Everybody seemed to be dressed to show off whatever it was that they wanted to have the character show off. It's really shallow, but again, comic book about big fight. I'm not coming into that looking for depth.

Gerard Butler chewed scenery like a dying man. Yes, and wasn't that the point?

[triadruid.livejournal.com]

Yeah, but he started long before he was ever in danger. ;)

Also and unrelated, can you change the title of the boardgames.meetup to not-February? I just posted about it in kansascity.

[featherynscale.livejournal.com]

For you, I do this thing.